KENTUCKY BUTTER CAKE WITH RUM SAUCE

Kentucky Butter Cake - The Southern Lady Cooks

This Kentucky Butter Cake recipe has been around for a long time because it is such a great cake!  Butter cake is very moist and the rum just makes it even better.  This recipe is a keeper.  Great to serve to family, friends and guests. Wonderful addition to any holiday gathering. It’s the perfect addition to any Christmas meal!

Ingredients for the Kentucky Butter Cake

Sugar

Eggs

Butter

Rum (If you don’t use alcohol, you can substitute vanilla extract or rum extract)

Buttermilk

All-purpose flour

Salt

Baking powder

Baking soda

Rum Sauce Ingredients

Sugar

Butter

Water

Rum, can use more (If you don’t use alcohol, you can substitute vanilla extract or rum extract)

I have made this cake with rum and with rum extract and it is delicious either way. I honestly think the rum extract has more flavoring. Since there is salt in the recipe I use unsalted butter, you are welcome to use whatever you prefer.

Some people don’t keep buttermilk on hand, if you are one of those people you can always make a buttermilk substitute

Love this comment: “Just made this Rum Cake: so easy even a GUY can do it! Thank you: it’s delicious.” – Victor

Kentucky Butter Cake - The Southern Lady Cooks

Kentucky Butter Cake- The Southern Lady Cooks
 
Are you reading our digital magazine, Front Porch Life? It’s full of great new recipes, country living, fantastic people, southern charm, cooking tips and so much more. We send it directly to your email so you can start reading, cooking and relaxing immediately! This is our premium content not found on our website. Join 1000’s of others today and start enjoying our magazine! 
Print Recipe
5 from 28 votes

Kentucky Butter Cake

This Kentucky Butter Cake is a classic! Perfect for any gathering. 
Prep Time15 mins
Cook Time1 hr
Total Time1 hr 15 mins
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American, southern
Keyword: Kentucky Butter Cake
Servings: 1 cake

Ingredients

  • 2 cups sugar
  • 4 eggs
  • 2 sticks butter softened
  • 2 teaspoons rum can use more(If you don’t use alcohol, you can substitute vanilla extract or rum extract)
  • 1 cup buttermilk
  • 3 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda

Rum Sauce Ingredients

  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1/3 cup butter
  • 3 tablespoons water
  • 2 teaspoons rum can use more (If you don’t use alcohol, you can substitute vanilla extract or rum extract)

Instructions

  • n a large bowl cream sugar, eggs, butter, and buttermilk together with mixer. Add flour, salt, baking powder, baking soda, and vanilla or rum and mix. Pour batter into a well-sprayed bundt pan or pan of your choice.
  • Bake in a preheated 325 degree oven for 55 to 60 minutes until done. Let cool in the pan at least 30 minutes before removing.

Rum Sauce Instructions

  • Combine all ingredients in a saucepan and cook over medium heat until fully melted. Do not boil! Pour over cake.

Notes

I take a skewer and poke holes in the cake, then use a turkey baster to put sauce into holes but you can just pour it over the cake. The cake will soak up the sauce.

 
Don’t Forget to Pin Kentucky Butter Cake.
 
 
Follow us on Instagram.
 
© The Southern Lady Cooks photos and text – All rights reserved. No copying, posting on other sites, or other uses allowed without written permission of the copyright holder.
 

Save

5 Secrets to Old-Fashioned
Southern Cooking

Tips, tricks & recipes to cook Southern food just like Grandma used to!

FREE EMAIL BONUS

Similar Posts

82 Comments

  1. I have been baking this marvelous cake for almost 50 years and it is a family tradition. Our 4 sons and their families rely on having it at least twice a year. I have very successfully shipped this to them as well. Wrap well in plastic cling wrap, then sturdy foil wrap, then into a good box, well supported by whatever you have. Our sons loved getting them mailed to them in college! Btw, I also think the pure vanilla and rum extracts are more flavorful than plain rum.

  2. I have baked this cake twice in 2 days. In the first one, I used rum extract. In the second one, I used spiced rum. When using the same amount of each In the cake batter, the rum extract was more flavorful. I used the amount of rum extract in the rum sauce with the first one and doubled the amount of spiced rum with the second one. The rum extract was definitely more flavorful. Both are really good. With the first cake, I poked holes in the cooled cake and spooned the rum sauce over the cake. A lot of it ran off and didn’t soak in the cake. With the second cake, while it was still very warm and in the pan, I poked holes in the bottom of the cake and poured half of the sauce over the cake. It soaked it right up! I then dumped the cake out of the pan and repeated on top. It soaked up all of the rum sauce.5 stars

    1. Thank you for this.I just took the cake out of the oven and was wondering if I should put the sauce on before I take it out of the pan.I used a tube pan. I think I will put on half then the rest when I take it out of the pan.

  3. i am anxious to try this recipe. i just have a small question, after you let the cake cool in the pan, do you pour the rum sauce over cake while still in the pan or do you remove cake onto a serving plate and pour sauce over it then?

    1. Thank you for this incredible recipe. I modified this recipe to be dairy free. I used vegan butter and for the buttermilk, I substituted oat milk with a tablespoon of vinegar. It came out absolutely amazing! My husband said it was one of the best cakes he’s ever had! I highly recommend ❤️5 stars

  4. Baking as we speak. Making the rum sauce…I turned my back and it was boiling! Your directions say do NOT boil… with an exclamation point! Should I throw this out right now? What is going to happen? I used my last tiniest bit of rum so would prefer to salvage it….what do you think?

    1. Thank you so much Scarlett. I am happy you enjoy the recipes. Merry Christmas to you and yours and Happy New Year, too.

  5. This is a family favorite now. I don’t buy butter milk so I use milk with a splash of vinegar in it. It’s a go to substitute & comes out wonderful!5 stars

  6. For those who asked about the metric weight of a cup of butter :
    1 cup of butter = 220 grams of butter.
    I usually replaced the 1 cup with the “local” 200gram block of butter with great success

  7. My mom passed this recipe to me, and I have been baking this cake for over 40 years. I always made in a tube pan, and used vanilla flavoring instead of rum (I am going to try with rum)! I poke holes in the cake and drizzle the icing on while the cake is still in the pan and still warm. This is a wonderful cake with fresh strawberries, or homemade ice cream. A wonderful coffee cake. There is never a crumb left!5 stars

  8. Have you tried freezing this cake? This cake sounds really good and it would be nice make it and take out of the freezer when you need it.

    1. No, I have not tried freezing it, sorry. You might try freezing a little of it to see how it does. I don’t see why you couldn’t freeze it but I might not put the rum sauce on it if I did.

    2. I have had this recipe for years. It does well is the freezer! It is good to eat frozen as well with a warm cup of coffee.

    1. Thank you so much, Victor. So happy you like the recipes and enjoy the cake. Happy to have you on the site. Have a great week ahead.

  9. I used vanilla in place for the rum. I didn’t have butter milk so I subed with milk & a little vinegar added to it. This is now Hubby’s favorite cake. I made one last week & last night he wanted to know when I was making it again!! Lol! Thank you for this easy & yummy recipe!5 stars

    1. Happy you all are enjoying this recipe, Emily! Thank you for letting me know and make that man another cake. lol

  10. Just saw the recipe, read it to my husband, so now he’s off to the liquor store! Guess what I’m baking tonight???

  11. Planning to try this cake. Wondering if anyone out there has determined if it needs more rum than the 2 teaspoons in the recipe. I have used another recipe that uses a cake mix that calls for 1/2 cup of rum in the cake and the glaze! Quite a difference ! I prefer to use this one from scratch. Thanks

  12. When I “shared” this cake recipe on my Facebook page, one of my friends had seen it and asked me to make it for her birthday cake. I just finished writing down all the ingredients & directions. Her birthday is in December. After she has a chance to eat some of this cake, I’ll get her response on how she liked it and post her comments.

  13. I tried the Butter Cake this weekend, and had great reviews…Loved it…even though it was a little more golden than yours. Thanks for this wonderful recipe 🙂5 stars

  14. THANKSGIVING IS MY DAY TO TRY THIS CAKE ..GOTA MAKE TWO BECUSE MY DAUGHTER GONNA WANT ONE..AN IT LOOKS SO GOOD..ILL KEEP U POSTED ON HOW I LIKED IT…THANKS N ADVANCE..

    1. There is a pumpkin cake listed under cakes but it is not a pound cake. All cakes are listed under Cakes, Candy and Cookies on the right hand side of any page on the site.

  15. Thank you so much for sharing your recipes. I have always said “there’s nothing better than a Southern Lady or Church Lady cookbook. You know going in ALL recipes are amazing!5 stars

  16. Q: Have you ever tried it with Brandy instead of Rum for the sauce? I’ve got some Brandy sitting here from an Amish Friendship Cake Starter recipe & not sure what to do with it (other than what most might do & drink it – LOL!), so wondered if this might be a good substitute…

  17. I recently switched to using organic flour in cakes and cookies and have used half a cup of sugar then half a cup of splenda was wondering if when using organic flour in your cake would that alter the taste and also the splenda?

  18. Close to the Rum Cake I make…….but I pour about l cup of chopped pecans in the bottom of pan….then I pour in batter……Yum

  19. I’ve done a cake like this before, and I use either a regular dark rum, or a spiced dark rum, and either way, it turns out great.

  20. My grandma in Somerset, KY made a butter cake when I was a little girl and I loved it. I’m going to make this and hope for all those wonderful memories.

      1. You probably didn’t notice-the wrapper has the measurements on it as well.

      2. could you please tell me a weight measurement for the butter, we don’t work in sticks or cup measures for butter here in NZ! thanks in advance 🙂

  21. Wonderful cake used your recipe many times and love it , close to my aunts lemon rum spice cake and yes it can be altered to be low cholesterol but sometimes ya just don’t want to! Lol thanks again for the post!5 stars

      1. Sorry, I just saw this comment. I hope your cake turned out o.k. Yes, you let it cool, then pour the sauce over the cake.

  22. So nice all your recipies But i don’t know how much is the weight of the blocks of butter…or sticks…sorry here in Greece maybe we have diferent measurments Thank you so much for your nice recipies..<3

  23. I made the cake today. I used Coconut Rum (because I had just enough to do the cake and wanted to finish the bottle before buying a new one). It is excellent!!!5 stars

    1. It is alcohol. I changed the recipe to reflect that. Thanks for bringing to my attention. You could use vanilla extract or rum extract in place of the alcohol.

  24. How long will this cake keep with the rum sauce? I am looking for a recipe that I could ship after baking…

  25. Perhaps I’m just a stickler for the Oxford comma, but are you saying to use rum, but may use vanilla extract if no rum? Or are we to use rum extract?

  26. I do this recipe but using a cake mix and a few other ingredients added. I use the same rum sauce with it.

  27. Looks Yummy I will make it. Anything that gets a little liquor before it comes to the table sounds wonderful to me !!!! Thanks

  28. My youngest daughter used to make this cake when she was learning to cook. It really is a wonderfully delicious cake!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating